Riker: “I wonder if one doesn’t have to have age and wisdom to appreciate that, sir.”
The search for the fountain of youth is an ongoing theme in literature and other forms of media. It seems if you are an admiral who has negotiated treaties all over the galaxy that you might be the one to find it. But why would you want to use it?
Admiral Jameson originally wanted to reverse his aging to cure his Iverson's disease and to become young and healthy again, not what he sees as a useless invalid. I wish they had spent more time exploring this issue. Jameson's wife loves him for who he is and wants to spend their remaining time together. She is frustrated that his time in space has kept them apart, not that he has a disabling disease. They could have spent some time exploring how being a Starfleet commander affects your family or why disability is so hard for alpha type men.
Although Picard comments on the wisdom that comes with age, it seems that Jameson has not changed much. He is stubborn, arrogant and certain of his path. Jameson, without consideration for his wife or even his own health, takes an overdose of a dangerous drug so that he can right another poor judgment 45 years ago. His impulsiveness is a nice counterpoint to Picard, who seems to be much more considered and balanced. Picard's moral compass is strong and evident where Jameson's is egocentric. It was somewhat painful to watch Picard be outranked by someone who was obviously less skilled in command.
Like most of this first season, the writing for this episode is hit and miss. Trying to go back and right a wrong you committed a long time ago is a good basis for a story, but throwing in the fountain of youth just mucked things up. It has seemed so far that sometimes they get a cool idea (hey, what if there was a 'native' cure that reversed aging?) and then just throw it into another plot line (what if an admiral had to go back and face the music after interpreting the prime directive in a disastrous way?). Of course there were other plot holes - would Picard actually let a petty dictator put him or anyone else to death? Why couldn't they just find the hostages themselves and beam them up, especially once they knew it was Karnas that had them? Wouldn't Karnas have to face some consequences for taking Federation citizens hostage?
I'm not going to comment too much on the sub-standard make-up or the overacting of the petty dictator. The less said about cheesy death scenes the better. What I missed in this episode the most was some more character development or even a bit more about the Star Trek 'verse. I know that everyone is working to get their groove in this first season, but missed opportunities are making me a bit sad.
Bits and Pieces
Tasha Yar is a great shot. Too bad they had to beam out of that fight. She was taking the Mordans out.
Beverly and Jean Luc were flirting again. Not exactly a news flash.
At least the show was willing to show the possibility of sex in older people's lives.
Yes, Jean Luc, other people than Troi can have gut feelings. I bet you have them once in a while.
Jameson: “63 people came away safe, but millions died on Mordan because I delivered those weapons.”
Jameson: “There’s no substitute, Lieutenant, for a little personal reconnoiter.”
Data: “Their phasers, sir, set on kill.”
Picard: “Thank you, Data. I have heard the sound before.”
Picard: “Not good is a galactic understatement.”
Ann Jameson: “But you never asked if I wanted it. It’s just like you, Mark, to assume that what you felt was right was the only answer. “
Karnas: "Rest, Jameson. Your long night and mine are over.”