Home Featured TV Shows All TV Shows Movie Reviews Book Reviews Articles Frequently Asked Questions About Us

Manifest: Bogey

Eagan: “What the hell is going on, Professor?”

A lion shows up in a Calling; Ben and Eagan are forced to work together; and Saanvi confesses to Michaela.

Zeke and Michaela invite Jared and Sarah over. One reason is to show approval to the couple, but Michaela also wants to know if Zeke gets any vibes from Sarah. This may seem a little self-serving – Zeke warned Cal about abuse of gifts in the last episode – but Sarah is the daughter of the Major, a woman who harassed and tortured the passengers. It’s not so much self-serving as it is self-preservation. Zeke is willing to help, but he doesn’t seem to be able to control his empathic abilities. They come and they go.

Several passengers experience a Calling including a dark cloud, which is a symbol of Eureka, the way a heartbeat signals Evie’s family to Michaela. Ben also gets a flood! He’s freaking out at the water pouring into the garage – he thinks the washer broke – only to have Grace tell him that there is no water. We see again that it’s useful to have people not getting the Callings in the vicinity, so we can distinguish between normal world and Calling world. Also, the same Calling drives Eagan – also getting soaked, but also threatened by a lion, which is weird – to the Stones’ front door.

Although most of Manifest is shown from the perspective of the Stones and a few other “good” characters, such as Saanvi, Zeke, Jared and Vance, sometimes the Callings seem to have another attitude. Grace does not want Eagan in their house, and Ben does not want Eagan in his garage, but apparently the Callings want them to work together. I’m not sure that Eagan’s presence was needed to resolve this Calling – Ben could have figured out everything on his own – but his being in Ben’s garage exposes him to a lot of additional information (and Eagan is always fun). He flips through the pages of the Al-Zuras journal – and sees Saanvi in the screaming crowd, which we in the audience have noticed before but apparently was missed by Ben.

Bleeding eyes are also noticed by Michaela, actually on Michaela in her reflection, which is an indication that she needs to do more than the others. After consulting with Ben, they figure out Saanvi is in trouble. Michaela abandons her own dinner party to go to Eureka. Saanvi’s eyes are bleeding for real, and have been since she inflicted simulated dark lightning on the fragment of Noah's Ark.

Olive, going to the campus to do research, discovers (through Levi) the story of the lion with bleeding eyes, a flood, and the village who lied to the woman. I loved this story, as I loved the previous story of the last trial. Again we have emphasized to us that responsibility is not always individual, but can be collective. I think this such a wonderful metaphor for the fate of the human race, and I am so thrilled with how Manifest is making a point of it.

Sarah is beautiful with Beverly. My father had dementia before he died, and I remember dealing with the frustration and confusion. After a while, there is little point in arguing with a dementia sufferer's worldview; you just go with it. Sarah accepts her role as Michaela – maybe Bev would call any young white woman that name – and helps clean her up and takes her to bed.

Olive is nasty to Angelina. I can understand that Olive must be getting annoyed at sharing her wardrobe and her mother and her little sister with her. Of course, Angelina is in a really lousy position: when she fled Costa Rica, she had absolutely nothing. But the hair coloring is weird. The trying to press close to Levi is weird, especially as Levi seems interested in Olive. On the other hand, what about TJ? It seems rather greedy of Olive to claim both young men. On the other other hand, Angelina is tiresome.

I love how Vance looks on the interaction between Michaela and Saanvi. He is ready to continue to lie, but he’s also willing to let Saanvi tell the truth. The truth puts Michaela in a terrible position. She’s a cop, and Saanvi just confessed to a murder.

Bev tells Zeke an uncomfortable truth about his insecurity – Michaela expected their marriage to last only one night – but Zeke doesn’t interpret it as her having insight. No, he thinks she’s feeling what he was feeling, which is interesting.

Title musings: “Bogey” is the title of the episode, and in aviation it means an unidentified enemy aircraft (or at least it’s suspected to be an enemy, if it’s not identified, how do you know? I’m not sure who the enemy is in this episode: Eagan? Angelina? Dr. Gupta? A nice title.

Bits and pieces

Bleeding eyes are really creepy. The makeup in Manifest isn’t always perfect in this, but the concept is cool.

Timing? Thirty-three days have passed since the driftwood fragment arrived, so that puts us sometime in August of 2020.

It must have been annoying for Josh Dallas (Ben Stone) and Ali Lopez-Sohaili (Eagan Tehrani) to stand in water for the filming of several scenes, and to keep switching between dry Ben and wet Ben. Also, they would have to be very, very careful not to electrocute anyone.

Has Grace had any Callings since giving birth to Eden? I don’t think so.

Washers are often in the basement just so they can’t flood the rest of the house if a pipe breaks. On the other hand, this may mean going up and down the stairs for a homeowner to do that laundry.


Jared: Good on you, man, hosting the most awkward dinner party ever.
Zeke: Ha! Good on you to come.
Jared: Yeah, well, Mick didn't really give me much of a choice.

Grace: Ben, the man kidnapped you. Why would you even let him in the door?
Ben: I don't like this any more than you do, but he's excellent at deciphering the Callings, and, clearly, the Universe wants us to work together.
Grace: I don't want you going anywhere with him. And I don't want him in my house.

Beverly: Michaela, help me, please. Help me. Michaela!
Sarah: Yes, ma'am. Here we go. It's gonna be okay.

Olive: Really? Because I see you. I see you sucking up to my mom and pretending to be Eden's big sister and pushing me out so you can...
Angelina: No, I wouldn't do that. I – I just wanted to be a part of this family. You guys are all so nice.
Olive: Nice? We pity you.

Saanvi: You both know that you're not gonna fix me. Once I go on a vent, I'm not gonna come back.
Michaela: Saanvi, you have to let her do whatever she can to save you right now.
Saanvi: She can't save me. No one can.
Michaela: Saanvi, your tears of blood, your body breaking down, it's because you can't get Callings anymore, which is why my Calling led me to you. It's about a lie. What are you hiding?

Michaela: You're not the only one who's taken a life. Me. Zeke. He felt responsible for his sister's death. But he made amends, he followed the Calling, and he survived his Death Date.
Saanvi: That's not the same.
Michaela: No, it is not, because you thought the Major had a cure for Zeke, and on top of that, she kidnapped and tortured passengers. She killed people, Saanvi, so if her death isn't justifiable, I don't know whose is.
Saanvi: But still, like, how do I redeem myself from murder?
Michaela: I wish I knew. But the Calling, it wanted you to come clean. Maybe that's the first step.
Saanvi: Now what? I just confessed to murder. You're a cop. You have a responsibility.

Overall rating

Lots of good stuff in this episode: Saanvi finally confesses; Eagan is back; I love the stories and the collective responsibility. Three and a half out of four imaginary lions.

Victoria Grossack loves math, birds, Greek mythology, Jane Austen and great storytelling in many forms.


  1. While Olive was being somewhat cruel to Angelina, I was completely creeped by Angelina Single White Female-ing Olive. That is not something a well individual would do.

    Eagan is wonderful and awful at the same time. Great character.

  2. I am unfamiliar with "Single White Female-ing." But I agree that Angelina is totally messed up, not a surprise with her parents.

  3. It's a creepy 1992 movie where a woman's roommate starts imitating her, clothes and hairstyle, etc.


  4. I appreciate that you’re being careful with Angelina, Victoria, so as to not give away spoilers by accident. But yeah, while I do think Olive was a bit nasty to Angelina regarding the “pity” line, the patter’s very very worrisome.

    Why is Ben so damn trusting around Eagan? I wouldn’t take my eyes off the little shit. He’s smart, capable, good looking, yet totally self-serving. As bad as the Preacher guy.

    I found this episode confusing in regards to Eureka. What do tremors have to do with Noah’s Ark? Did the tail fin disappear at the same time? Why did Saanvi’s confessing cure her and Ben & Eagan’s Callings? Was her bleeding eyes a Calling for her? I didn’t understand the lion/flood story, and how it fit into Saanvi’s condition .

  5. Hi, Amaye, I will answer some of your questions here. The Callings, which are apparently really insistent, make it clear to Ben that he must work with Eagan. Ben has learned to follow/obey the Callings because when he doesn't things turn out even worse.
    The Callings in this case are warning Ben and Eagan and Michaela that something is seriously wrong with Saanvi (the dark clouds indicate that it's something at Eureka, and Saanvie their mole at Eureka). The lion/flood/tears story indicate that it's a lie. In this case, the lie is about Saanvi having killed the Major. It's a pretty big sin, but when she confesses, and agrees to turn herself in, the Callings are resolved.
    The tail fin disappeared the moment that Saanvi killed the Major and the tremors started the moment Saanvi experimented on Noah's Ark. No one else caused tremors like that because the other experimenters weren't passengers.
    Hope this helps!


We love comments! We moderate because of spam and trolls, but don't let that stop you! It’s never too late to comment on an old show, but please don’t spoil future episodes for newbies.