Home Featured TV Shows All TV Shows Movie Reviews Book Reviews Articles Frequently Asked Questions About Us

Merlin: The Diamond of the Day, Part 2

“Everything you’ve done. I know now. For me, for Camelot. For the kingdom you helped me build. Thank you.”

Hic iacet Arthurus, rex quondam, rexque futurus.

Here lies Arthur, the once and future king.

After five seasons, sixty-five episodes, 'The Diamond of the Day' brought Merlin to a somewhat satisfying end. It wasn't a perfect episode, indeed there was much which annoyed the hell out of me (more on that later), but it did manage to wrap up Merlin and Arthur's story in a way that should please fans' hearts and minds. A word of warning: you will need hankies. Lots of hankies. This is going to get emotional.

Once again the writers managed to remain true to the popular legends while giving them the typical Merlin twist. As was prophesied, Arthur fell in battle at Camlann, slain by Mordred, who was then quickly killed by Arthur. Too quickly, if you ask me. The poor lad was killed before he could even utter a second line of dialogue. Even Evil Lord Lynly got a better send off than this. Poor Mordred. Ignored for most of the season, his character development rushed through in a single episode and then killed off without a second thought once he'd done what he was supposed to.

But enough about the druid boy. He's dead and there's nothing to be done about it. Time to get back to the really important issue here, namely the writer finally acknowledging that Merlin and Arthur, not Gwen and Arthur, is the central love story of this show. I don't know how anyone can watch this episode and still doubt the love these two have for each other. Even learning that Merlin had been lying to him all this time couldn't crush Arthur's love for his loyal servant.

The best part of the finale was their final road trip to Avalon, which more than made up for previous one's shocking Merthur shortage. This entire episode was just wall to wall Merthur action as Merlin finally, FINALLY, told Arthur his secret. Phew. I was worried that he was going to wait until Arthur uttered his last breath before decided to come out of the magical closet. True, I would've preferred if he'd told him, say, two seasons ago, but I am happy we got to have almost an entire episode devoted to Arthur dealing with this revelation.

It goes without saying that Colin Morgan and Bradley James both excelled themselves. They have never been better than they were here. Arthur was understandably hurt that the one person he trusted more than anyone just so happens to be a sorcerer. But since he has never shared his father's intense hatred for those who practice magic, he got over that rather quickly. Once he realised everything that Merlin has done for him over the years, he was so grateful he even apologised for treating him so badly agreed to give him two days off. Blimey. Arthur giving Merlin time off. He must be dying.

I will admit to getting a little misty eyed over their final scenes together. Even though I saw it coming five years ago, I was surprised at how much Arthur's death actually affected me. I've seen dozens of different versions of this story, from John Boorman's Excalibur to the horrendous First Knight with Sean Connery and Richard Gere (I was young and foolish and there was nothing else on). All have featured the death of Arthur in one way or another and none of them got so much as a single tear out of me.

But Merlin is different, because Merlin is the first screen version of the Arthurian legends I can think of to feature an Arthur I actually liked and cared about. He may have often been a pampered brat who couldn't even get dressed without Merlin's help, but I liked this version of the Once and Future King and was sad to see him die. Especially since he left poor Merlin heartbroken. We have never seen the young warlock cry this much before.

Merlin and Arthur's relationship is the cornerstone of the entire series and it was right that they be the focus of the final episode. The only downside was that this left little room for the other characters. While some got the endings they deserved, others weren't so lucky. I've already mentioned how underwhelming Mordred's death was, so now I'm going to rant for a bit about how angry I am about Morgana.

I have seen some seriously lame TV deaths in my time, from Tasha Yar getting zapped by that annoying oil monster, to Gwaine and Mordred in this very episode, but this one takes the cake. Along with Merlin, Arthur and Gwen, Morgana is one of the series' central characters as well as its principle villain. And that is how they decided to finish her story? Did the producers blow all the FX budget on Camlann that they couldn't afford to give us magical showdown between Merlin and Morgana that we'd all been patiently waiting for? I can't help but feel cheated. And I feel really sorry for poor Katie McGrath. She deserved better ending for her character than this.

I may not ship it, but I do feel for the Arwen shippers. This episode was not their friend. There was no big goodbye scene for their favourite couple. Or any kind of scene, for that matter. The last time Gwen saw her husband was in the previous episode when he leapt out of bed after getting that telepathic message from Merlin. Because of that final roll in the hay, I was convinced for much of the episode that they were going to reveal that Gwen was pregnant with Arthur's child. Well, I was wrong. With Arthur dead and no heir, Gwen is left to rule Camelot alone. Which is a much nicer fate then her legendary counterpart. The Guinevere of legend joined a convent and remained there until her death. Being the badass Queen of Camelot is a much better ending for Gwen. And, let's be honest, she really the best person for the job. Now that she knows the truth about Merlin, it is implied that Gwen will undo Uther's law and stop the persecution of those who practice magic.

She may have lost her husband, but Gwen still has Gaius (who is that rare wise mentor who doesn't actually die) and what remains of the Knights of the Round Table to help her rule the kingdom. Ever resilient, Sir Leon survived and continues to do what he has always done – loyally serve the ruler of Camelot and deliver crucial pieces of exposition. When we saw him chasing after Morgana, I wrongly assumed that Percival was going to catch up with Arthur and Merlin and take on Bedivere's role by returning Excalibur to the Lady of the Lake. Instead that role went to Merlin, which I think was a shame. It would've been nice for Percival to have something significant to do for once. At least he got his Samson moment.

And, like Leon, he also survived. Alas, the same could not be said of Gwaine. Poor Gwaine. In many of the legends he is killed during the battle with Mordred's forces. Our Gwaine manges to survive the battle only to die a little later at Morgana's hands. Along with Mordred and Morgana, the Knight with the most luscious of hair was granted a horribly rushed and disappointing death that served little purpose other than to let Morgana know where Arthur was and give Percival an excuse to cry.

I'm still not sure how I feel about the coda. It reminded me a lot of the ending of Battlestar Galactica, in that it came across as intrusive and unnecessary. And I could've done without the lousy CGI of Glastonbury Tor. However, part of me does like the idea of Merlin living forever in Glastonbury, watching over Arthur's resting place, waiting for his return, stopping only to attend the festival and grumble about the quality of this year's line up.

Merthur Moments

So many to chose from, but this one wins the prize:

Actual dialogue. I'm pretty certain that Merthur shippers everywhere went into meltdown when he said that.

Notes and Quotes

--Season 5 is the only season not to feature an appearance by Santiago Cabrera as Lancelot or Michael Cronin as Geoffrey of Monmouth.

--The swift end to the battle and Mordred's lame death are just two reasons why I think these final two episodes should've aired as one. Spreading the Battle of Camlann across two episodes was a serious mistake and upset the flow of the whole thing.

--Merlin told Arthur his secret right after the battle. Gwen figured it out not long after. And Morgana already knew. So why even bother having Old Merlin at all? It would have been so much better if we'd got to see the Merlin we know, the one we've followed for these past five years, being the all powerful wizard who saved the day and sent the Saxon's packing.

--We never found out what happened to Aithusa after he was sent away by Merlin. We know that the Great Dragon is dying, but where did Aithusa go?

Gwen: "Who is that?"
Gaius: "Someone truly remarkable."
Gwen: "You know him?"
Gaius: "Let's just say he deserves our gratitude."

Merlin: "You're bleeding."
Arthur: "That's all right. I thought I was dying."

Merlin: "I'm a sorcerer. I have magic. I use it for you, Arthur. Only for you."
Arthur: "Merlin, you are not a sorcerer. I would know!"

Gaius: "He can do far more than me, far more than you can ever imagine. Arthur, he doesn't just have magic, there are those who say he is the greatest sorcerer ever to walk the earth."
Arthur: "Merlin?"

Arthur: "You've lied to me all this time."

Arthur: "Why did you never tell me?"
Merlin: "I wanted to, but..."
Arthur: "What?"
Merlin: "You'd have chopped my head off."
Arthur: "I'm not sure what I'd have done."
Merlin: "And I didn't want to put you in that position."
Arthur: "That's what worried you?"

Arthur: "So you're not an idiot. That was another lie."
Merlin: "No, it's just another part of my charm."

Merlin: "I can't lose him! He's my friend!"
The Great Dragon: "Though no man, no matter how great, can know his destiny, some lives have been foretold, Merlin... Arthur is not just a king, he is the Once and Future King. Take heart, for when Albion's need is greatest, Arthur will rise again. It has been a privilege to have known you, young warlock. The story we have been a part of will live long in the minds of men."

There's nothing more for me to say but thank you to the cast and crew of Merlin for the last five years. The show has had more than its share of ups and downs over the years, and while the final season was mostly disappointing for me, I am sorry to see it come to an end.

Three out of four immortal wizards dancing to Muse as they rock the Pyramid Stage.
Mark Greig has been writing for Doux Reviews since 2011. More Mark Greig.


  1. I think, as a realisation of the Arthurian legend, Merlin was ultimately a failure. Arthur never really developed into the king of mythology. After Uther's death he really should have grown up, but they failed to develop any? of the characters in a realistic way. Which makes the likelihood of Arthur being remembered as a great king, pretty remote.

    As a 'young adult' show, however, as you say, Arthur was a likeable king and Merlin a cool sidekick. And the writers did manage to inject some subtle humour into their relationship (and also some not-so subtle), I would just like to have seen a season or so of them behaving as equals and friends. Arthur's confession of friendship at the very end hardly made up for five years of him behaving like a dick.

    Well worth the watch, though. I'm not sure I'd recommend it to a friend, but I don't regret having watched it. Even during the worst episodes there was always Gwen and Morgana to keep me company. The memory of their cleavages will likely live on longer than my memory of the show.

  2. I agree that Merlin is not the best screen realisation of the Matter of Britain (still better than Camelot, though), but as a Saturday afternoon teatime adventure series it did it's job and did it rather well, far better than the likes of Robin Hood and Primeval.

  3. This ending really annoyed me I must admit - I know it's pretty much the canonical legend and normally that's fine, but this Arthur was just too young and immature. I expected them to save him.

    More importantly, I watched this while spending Christmas Eve alone, and I wanted to be thrilled and cheered up. Instead, I got 45 minutes of a beloved character dying. That's what 'ER' is for. I'd probably have reacted better to this episode if they'd aired it really on any other other day of the year. Except perhaps Christmas Day (do not get me started on this year's other well known Christmas offerings! Leave the tragedy to Eastenders please, that's what it's there for!)

    But then, I really like First Knight, so my opinion may be unreliable ;)

  4. I liked First Knight, too. Although I saw it in theaters, so I was pretty young.


    Oh, I was 14. Is that young enough that I don't have to be embarrassed?

    [Pulls out calculator]

    Wait...I mean I was 11. Because my New Year's resolution is to start lying about my age. It feels so good to be 29 again!

  5. *sigh* It's over!!! *sob*

    Seems like everyone's in agreement we would have liked the series to last longer so we could what things would have been like with Arthur and Merlin as equals!

    Arthur is definitely too young to have died here. He hasn't built the wonderful world of Albion as was prophecized! Just the joyful kingdom of Camelot. He's supposed to be the High King of Britain and stem the tide of Saxon invaders to give Celtic Britain a breathing space before the Dark Ages! *grumble, grumble*

    And yes. Camlann was waaaaay too short! Even watching both episodes back to back as I did. Merlin's magic ended it too quickly. We should have gotten a showdown with Morgana! But we didn't even get that at her death... argh!!!

    But the wonderful half-hour ending with Merlin and Arthur almost makes up for everything else...

    But I had soooooooo hoped (against hope) that they'd break with tradition and let Arthur live! So we could at least imagine the two doing great things together!

    Death that pissed me off the most? Gwaine!!! Totally unnecessary!!! And we still haven't gotten a decent reaction from him re. Merlin! *grumble*

    Major smiles at the thought of Gwen as Queen of Camelot though! Can you imagine how Uther must be squirming in his grave?! lol!

    Re First Knight. I'll have to re-watch it for my blog... but I'm not looking forward to it at all! I have vague memories of having seen it in the cinema. There's no way I would have missed out on that film what with my King Arthur obsession and it being Sean Connery... but woah! I remember it as being really bad! My memories might be influenced by my intense dislike of Richard Gere though... we'll see!

  6. Here's my take on the series finale:

    Merlin 512-513: The Diamond of the Day, series finale

    Next summer I'll rewatch the rest of the series and write about those episodes and the series as a whole. You can be sure I'll be linking back to your reviews Mark, I've really enjoyed them! And it's been fun chatting about them here (none of my friends here watch it). Can't wait for those in the US to get a chance to see them and read what they have to say! Are you going to update the dates on the posts to remind those Stateside about your reviews?

    Now I just have two more Arthurian-related posts to write and then I'm moving on to Robin Hood for a spell...

  7. Meh. I pretty much agree with all of your assessments, Mark. It really is too bad the writers got caught up in unnecessary tangents this season rather than fully developing the "good to evil" tragedy for Mordred. About the only thing I "liked" about the ending was Merlin and Arthur's story. And, I did not like the "zoom to the future" at the end. It was very jarring and felt out of place.
    Oh well, as you say above, "as a Saturday afternoon teatime adventure series it did it's job and did it rather well" I have to agree with that. It was a nice show I could watch with my daughter and not worry about covering her eyes/ears. I hope to see Colin, Bradley, Angel, and Katie soon. They are terrific young actors who really grew on the show (I especially thought Bradley's work got better as the series progressed). Thanks for the reviews.

  8. You're welcome, Snooze. Glad you've been enjoying the reviews. I hope to go back and finish the rest of the series off some time next year.


We love comments! We moderate because of spam and trolls, but don't let that stop you! It’s never too late to comment on an old show, but please don’t spoil future episodes for newbies.