Home Featured TV Shows All TV Shows Movie Reviews Book Reviews Articles Frequently Asked Questions About Us

Castle: Fool Me Once

“Thai food is pleasing to the toe.”

The case this week is about a con man who, it turns out, has a heart of gold. Sound like anyone we know?

Castle, himself, is a con man to a degree. He has spent his adult life putting on a persona, rarely revealing the man he truly is. He writes books for a living, spending his time in a fictional world of his own creation. Again, not unlike Fletcher. In case we have missed the connection, there is a conversation between Castle and Beckett in which he admits that he is impressed with Fletcher. At Beckett’s appalled response, Castle hastens to add that it is not personal, it is professional. They are both storytellers.

Because he and Fletcher share so many characteristics, Castle is more willing to believe the best of the man. Beckett, on the other hand, is cynical and untrusting right up until the end. There is a wonderful scene in which Castle asks her if she believes people can change. Her experience in the NYPD has shown her that it is rare. It is to her credit, however, that at the end she appreciates what Fletcher was trying to do.

The subplot with the violin teacher reveals more to us than stories with Alexis often do. Because of the way Castle is with women, he does not trust good-looking, talented men. He is all too aware of the cons they run to entice women. As a result, he is going to protect Alexis, even when she doesn’t need it. I like the fact that it is Beckett who puts Castle back on track with his daughter. Beckett is compassionate after Alexis berates Castle, but she forces him to face the truth of his actions.

There are cons running throughout this episode, many of them just fun. Ryan pretends to have hurt his back so that Esposito has to carry all the stuff from Fletcher’s apartment. When Ryan and Esposito confront Castle about his feelings for Beckett, he doesn’t answer the question directly. Castle’s CIA contact is a shadowy figure who never reveals whom he really is.

The most fun con, however, is the one that Beckett runs on Castle throughout the length of the episode. For obvious reasons, he is anxious to know how she feels about Heat Wave. Beckett refuses to massage his ego and maintains that she has been too busy to read it. She does, uncharacteristically, leave work so that she can go home and read it in the bath with a glass of wine. Later, she hides in the bathroom stall, only to get caught by her savvy partner.

In spite of all the conning, Caskett have really gelled as a partnership. The scene where they deduce the solution to the mystery is fantastic. The two of them go back and forth with the story, edging closer and closer to each other with each sentence. The scene ends when they both reach the same conclusion at the same time. They exchange smiles that make my shipper heart melt.

At the end of the episode, Beckett is being very sweet with Elise and tells her that Fletcher changed his ways because he wanted to be a better man for the woman he loved. Castle’s face is a study -- even the first time through this episode, I knew foreshadowing when I saw it.

A good, solid standalone. Three out of four snowfalls in an Upper West Side apartment.


-- Firefly reference: When Castle puts on gloves at the crime scene, he takes a good, long look at them. They are blue.

-- Molly O’Quinn actually plays the violin.

-- Beckett’s reactions to Patty Schultz are hilarious. Although she is normally the straight man to Fillion, Katic is a wonderful comedic actress in her own right.

-- I agree with Castle. The Sting is not only the best con movie ever, it is one of the best movies ever. It didn’t win twenty Oscars, only seven. Those seven included, however, Best Picture, Best Director and Best Original Screenplay.

-- This is the first episode to use “shut the front door.” If you are interested, you can now buy a t-shirt with that slogan and the Castle logo. How do I know? Santa put one in my stocking a couple of years ago.

-- Would anyone else like to know how it is possible to kill someone with an ice cream scoop?

-- In my copy of Heat Wave, the sex scene is, indeed, on page 105. It’s good, but I wouldn’t exactly characterize it as steamy.


Castle: “That was awesome! I mean, well, obviously it was horrible, but that’s not the Arctic.”

Castle: “Oh, I see what you’re doing.”
Beckett: “I’m not doing anything.”
Castle: “Oh, yes, you are. Yes, you are. You’re trying to push my buttons. But, it’s not gonna work.”
Beckett: “Really?” ‘Cause it seems to working just great.”

Esposito: “Why do you care, Castle? Do you have some unresolved feelings?”
Ryan: “Hmmm.”
Castle: “For Beckett? The woman hates con movies.”

Beckett: “You have a guy in the CIA?”
Castle: “When are you going to learn? I’ve got a guy everywhere.”

Beckett: “I hate this case.”
Castle: “I know. Isn’t it great!?!”

ChrisB is a freelance writer who spends more time than she ought in front of a television screen or with a book in her hand.


  1. I don't remember the case of the week very well, but I do remember you forgot one 'con.' Beckett convinces Castle she hates conman movies. :)

    The thing with the gloves is hilarious. Most shows are scared to reference their leads' earlier work. Castle, thankfully, has never been one of those shows. Castle has picked up some Chinese (from a TV show, he says), the catalyzer from "Out of Gas" is in Castle's apartment, and let's not forget the epic "Vampire Weekend." It's my second favorite episode of the series, so hurry up and get there! gahhh!

  2. I thought it was Thai food is pleasing to the tongue?

  3. Laura -- you could be right. The version I am watching for season two does not have captioning, so I am guessing sometimes. Your version makes more sense, but I like the idea of the CIA using a code that is absurd.

  4. Some episodes of Raines aren't captioned. Have you ever tried transcribing Jeff Goldbum without aid? It's like staring into the sun.

  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

  6. I love the scene in the precinct bathroom. It may be my favorite of the series. There have been times where I've played it on a loop, just to hear the way Katic says "ww-what?" (along with the "shields are down!" expression on her face).


We love comments! We moderate because of spam and trolls, but don't let that stop you! It’s never too late to comment on an old show, but please don’t spoil future episodes for newbies.