Home Featured TV Shows All TV Shows Movie Reviews Book Reviews Articles Frequently Asked Questions About Us

The Musketeers: Friends and Enemies

“I’m D’Artagnan. Please think kindly of my name, if you think of it at all.”

There are some stories that are so well known and so well loved that adapting them for a screen, either large or small, is taking a risk. The purists will be frustrated by the changes; people new to the story may not grasp why it is so beloved.

Let me begin at the beginning by saying that I have never read Dumas’s novel. But, as with so many other stories, this one has become so much a part of the collective consciousness that I feel as if I have. I know the characters and I know the basic plot.

Which is the first thing this pilot did well. We are quickly introduced to the main players, expected to know basically who they are and what role they will play in the drama. The writer, Adrian Hodges, is able to pace the pilot accordingly and give us what we all tuned in to see.

What I want from a version of The Musketeers is swashbuckling fun. I want sword fights, big hats with feathers, kings and queens, romance, a bit of drama, and a few laugh out loud moments. This pilot hit every one of those notes.

It goes without saying that any drama will succeed or fail on its actors, no matter how well written or filmed. Unsurprisingly, the BBC found superb actors for every one of the major roles. All of them managed to imbue his or her character with subtle moments that gave each a personality. These are not just musketeers; they are individuals who have chosen this life. Each has issues; each is proud of what he does; each is extremely easy to look at.

Athos (Tom Burke) drinks too much, mourning a lost love whom he may have murdered. He is the obvious leader of the group, yet respects his colleagues enormously. Aramis (Santiago Cabrera) is the ladies man, sleeping with the Cardinal’s mistress. My favorite of the three is Porthos (Howard Charles). A man with a gambling problem, he has a sly sense of humor that made me laugh often.

These three are all under the command of Treville (Hugo Speer) who has issues and an agenda of his own. There is a brilliant scene, rather near the beginning of the episode, that shows us exactly who he is. He tells King Louis that he has never lied to him and never will. The Cardinal tries to trip him up and Treville lies. What is telling, however, is that he lies to the Cardinal, not the king. His honor is intact.

As good as these four are, the entire construct would fail without a strong D’Artagnan. Luke Pasqualino has the unenviable task of bringing an incredibly complex character to life without making him a parody. Mission accomplished. D’Artagnan is hellbent on revenge, yet he is also young, impulsive, and horny. He is very capable with a sword, a musket, and his fists — all of which he uses in the cold open.

With more than a passing nod to any good rom-com, D’Artagnan and Constance (Tamla Kari) have a meet-cute that made me invest in them as a couple immediately. As she is married, I am very interested to see where this romance goes as infidelity is not something that is often portrayed in a good light. Nor, should it be.

You can’t have heroes without villains. Peter Capaldi plays Cardinal Richelieu to perfection. He is power hungry and cunning, dispatching anyone who stands in his way without blinking. Capaldi plays the scene where the Cardinal has his mistress killed with incredible subtlety. On the one hand, the ruthlessness of the task is evident, yet there is a sadness on his face as she dies.

There is a side to all of the Cardinal’s plotting and planning that makes sense. Frankly, someone has to run the country because King Louis XIII (Ryan Gage) is not up to the task. His queen, Anne, (Alexandra Dowling) seems much more capable.

Milady de Winter (Maimie McCoy) is another perfect villain. Although we don’t spend a lot of time with her in the pilot, it is clear that she can go toe to toe with the Cardinal and more than hold her own. Not above using her sexuality to further her agenda, she sleeps with D’Artagnan and, we learn in the final reveal of the episode, is the woman whom Athos is mourning. What a great set-up for further complications down the road.

Which leads me to the strongest aspect of this episode and the reason I fell in love with it so quickly. The women are wonderfully drawn characters and are not just there to show us their breasts as they sleep with our heroes. Constance, Queen Anne, and Milady are all complex women, with minds and abilities of their own. The men treat these women as people, not simply as sexual conquests — a refreshing change.

My only quibble with the pilot, and it is a small one, is that the story was a tad perfunctory. Missing letters, a missing musketeer, and a bad guy who is setting up the good guy on behalf of our big bad. The tension level is not that high as there is no way Athos will die in the pilot. I’m more than willing to overlook this problem, however, as the main point of the pilot is to introduce us to the characters with whom we will spend the next ten weeks. In that, this episode was a rousing success.

It is rare that I become so invested in a show so quickly, but this one pulled me in immediately. Three and a half out of four Spanish doubloons.


The series is filmed in Prague that, combined with a touch of CGI, does an excellent job of standing in for the France of 1630.

The tension between the Musketeers (the King’s army) and the Red Guard (the Cardinal’s army) is interesting as both have the same basic purpose.

The score is magnificent.


King Louis: “[The birds] are born to be shot, like rabbits and poets.”

Cardinal: “A great king must be seen to be fair. He cannot have favorites.”
King Louis: “Unless it’s you, you mean.”

D’Artagnan: “Prepare to fight. One of us dies here.”
Porthos: “Now, that’s the way to make an entrance.”

Cardinal: “Our plan did not include the murder of the Spanish traitor, Mendoza. He was still useful to me.”
Milady: “He was a bad lover and a terrible bore.”

Aramis: “You come to Paris to kill Athos and end up saving his life. After a few drinks, I’m sure he’ll appreciate the irony.”

ChrisB is a freelance writer who spends more time than she ought in front of a television screen or with a book in her hand.


  1. I have read the books and in them pretty much everyone has a mistress and being married doesn't stop it. The implication in the book is that it was part of how the upper/middle class behaved. I have no idea how far the show will go with this.

  2. As Percysowner said that's how infidelity was regarded in the books. Usually adaptations get around this by making Constance mr Bonacieux's daughter, not wife. Anyway, time will tell. Nice review, and I do so love the show.

  3. I haven't tried this show yet. Now I'll have to. :)

  4. What percysowner and mazephoenix said is both correct for the books and the time period. Just about any novel you read on Paris from around that time goes on about "mistresses", seems like anybody who was anybody had one. But yes, interesting to see what they'll do on TV!

    As a very big Dumas fan in general and Musketeers in particular, I'll share my usual quibble with changes made to the story in adaptations: they're UNNECESSARY!!! Just once I'd like to see someone take the source material and show it to us as is! The novel is perfect for the serialised form (it was even written that way!), and plenty happens without having to add stuff in! *sigh* I guess this means we won't get the Queen's diamonds, Buckingham, poisoned wine, a picnic in conquered land... :p

    But it only took me a couple of episodes to get over my annoyance at the changes, in the end I couldn't help falling in love with this series! If for no other reason that the characters on the screen are true to their nature on page, and they are such wonderful characters!!! Plus yeah, lots of swashbuckling fun! :D

    I look forward to your reviews, will be a good reminder of the show to prepare for next season! ;)

  5. I've seen it now, and yes, it's very good. I especially liked the actors who play D'Artagnan and Porthos. Swashbuckling isn't my thing at all, so we'll see if it continues to grab me.


We love comments! We moderate because of spam and trolls, but don't let that stop you! It’s never too late to comment on an old show, but please don’t spoil future episodes for newbies.