Home Featured TV Shows All TV Shows Movie Reviews Book Reviews Articles Frequently Asked Questions About Us

Castle: Law & Boarder

“You really think it’s one of you? You two.”

Historically, Castle winds up its season with a five episode arc that ends with the season finale cliffhanger. This year, however, it is going out with a series of standalone episodes that are proving to be hit or miss. Last week was a hit. This week? A real miss.

This episode should have been much more than it was. The world of extreme sports, while not something I am overly involved in, is interesting and could have proven to be an ideal backdrop for a murder. Instead, we got a by-the-numbers procedural that held no surprises, no twists, no interesting characters and no fun. What the writers were hoping would be the twists were so absurd as to be laughable. Albanians? Really?

What saved this episode from being completely forgettable were the competitions that occurred between the characters we know and love. Beckett kept beating Castle at Scrabble (quixotic, indeed!) which annoyed him no end. Until the final scene when they forgo Scrabble for a game of strip poker. Perhaps it was because I was already bored, but the fact that Castle was fully clothed (at least as far as we could see) while Beckett sat there in her underwear irked the feminist in me.

The humor this week, as usual, came from Ryan and Esposito vying to see who would be Castle’s best man. Although I knew from the beginning whom Castle would pick, it was fun to watch these two try to one-up the other, go to Lanie for her decision, make the decision for their friend, and then try to shrug it all off at the end.

I was tempted to rate this with a one, but I will give it a two for the best man stuff. Two out of four pens and recipes that didn’t work.


— In a show about sports and competition, it is interesting that we peel back another layer of the Castle onion. He is extremely competitive.

— I had to look up Death Race 2000. Turns out it is a cult action film, made in 1975, in which a road race is run and the winner is the driver who kills the most pedestrians. Yeah, I’m not going to bother with that one. Rollerball, another movie about extreme sports issued in 1975, was also mentioned.


Castle: “‘Richard Castle. One word short.’ I cannot allow this to be my epitaph.” Beckett and Alexis bump fists. “I saw that.”

Beckett: “Well, I mean, I think catching killers is pretty extreme. And, then there’s marrying you.”
Castle: “Ah, yes. I admit I am extreme. Extremely handsome.”
Beckett: “Yep. With a high degree of difficulty.”

Beckett: “Castle, aren’t there more important things than winning?”
Castle: “Oh, that’s a notion created to comfort those who lose.”

Esposito: “I can’t believe we just got beat by a girl.”
Ryan: “Let’s never speak of this again.”

ChrisB is a freelance writer who spends more time than she ought in front of a television screen or with a book in her hand.


  1. I watch Castle with my mom and, as we are both big Scrabble fiends, we gasped when Beckett pulled out 'quixotic.' What was with Beckett's outfit for the majority of this episode? It looked like a cross between a riding outfit and a prep school uniform. So un-her.

    I also knew he'd pick Alexis. Hard to see how the boys could be mad about that; she is his daughter. Besides, I'm sure they'll still get to plan the bachelor party.

  2. I agree about the outfit, sunbunny. Also, the hair this week was bad. The ponytail was weird and the bun was too extreme.

    I had originally commented on them in the review, but decided that I had been negative enough. Glad you gave me an excuse to bring it back.


  3. I probably am the only one who liked the outfit and the hair, when she first appeared on screen I squealed!

    Regarding the rest of the episode I totally agree with the review, I even guess the bad guy! (which I usually don't, even when it's obvious)

  4. I think Beckett looks better when her gorgeous hair is down. When they put it up, they seem to always do it too tightly and it ages her. Even my mom said something and she never notices stuff like that.

  5. Two points:
    1) Regarding the attire in the strip poker game, Castle explicitly states that the shirt is all he still has on. So it's pretty clear they show wanted the situation where they both only had one thing left on. It still seems a bit contrived tho'...
    2) Castle's circle of friends, not counting Beckett, must all suck at Scrabble. In the first game, it took me just a few seconds to see a 20 point play, "holy", (the 'h' hits a double word score) and Beckett's play of "quixotic" is known to be worth 356 points, not the 314 Castle claimed.

  6. I was annoyed by the best man plot. I know right away Alexis will be Castle's best man, and 2 NYPD detectives couldn't intuit his choice? Asking Lanie to decide? Just smack of contrived sitcom plot that didn't make any sense. I liked when Beckett changed the game from Scrabble to strip poker though. We're told Castle only had his shirt on, no idea if Beckett had on anything else but the bra. In the 2nd Scrabble game Beckett was dropping oodles romantic hints but Castle was too competitive to be in the mood. Maybe Beckett just poured on the visual enticement to make sure Castle gets the hint this time.


We love comments! We moderate because of spam and trolls, but don't let that stop you! It’s never too late to comment on an old show, but please don’t spoil future episodes for newbies.