Home Featured TV Shows All TV Shows Movie Reviews Book Reviews Articles Frequently Asked Questions About Us

Lost: Outlaws

Sawyer: "Oh, that hog is going to suffer. I swear to God."

This may be the closest we'll get to a comic episode. I thought it was terrific.

This week's Most Obvious Symbolism was that huge, snarling boar, which was Sawyer's guilty conscience. And in the end, he couldn't kill it. Sawyer, a character I initially disliked intensely, is becoming one of my favorites. In many ways, the snarky, brash Sawyer is still that terrified little boy hiding under a bed.

Sawyer's mother loved him deeply, but Sawyer probably doesn't believe she did. He probably believes that the death of his parents was somehow his fault, even though that isn't possible (hence his acquisition of the killer's persona). He desperately needs someone to love him, but I'm certain that if someone did, he would probably push her away with both hands. Is that why Sawyer and Kate were alone and drunk and he didn't make a pass at her? Is he afraid subconsciously that she'll start to love him and that it won't be a one-night stand, being as they're stranded on an island and all?

The scene with Sawyer getting drunk with Jack's father was a surprise, hinting that the survivors have more interconnections than we thought. I was not surprised that Sawyer didn't tell Jack that his father really loved him and was proud of him; Sawyer has too much baggage for that, and feels too much resentment toward Jack. Jack is everything Sawyer probably wishes he could be. And of course, Jack is his main rival for Kate.

But I had a thought. We still don't know what Sawyer was arrested for in the "Hearts and Minds" flashback; he was shouting something about giving the bottle back. Was it the bottle he bought in this scene? Did Sawyer have something to do with Christian Shephard's death? Was that another reason why he didn't tell Jack?

"That's why the Red Sox will never win the damned series" was Christian Shephard's way of saying, "It's fate." The Sox have indeed won the pennant since the crash. Were the writers implying that what was happening on the Island was not fate? Plus, I thought the continuing joke that Australia was Hell was interesting. We could extrapolate that the survivors actually left Hell and are now in Purgatory, couldn't we? Would that make L.A. heaven?

On top of the Sawyer-and-boar main plot and the wonderful "I Never" drinking game, this episode was chock full of good scenes. I particularly loved Charlie and Hurley burying Ethan. Who thought a scene like that could be so wryly funny?

And then there was that bit where Locke told Sawyer and Kate about his sister Jeannie and the dog. (Kate: "So you're saying the dog was your sister?" Locke: "Well, that would be silly.") There was a reason for the story. It was about how we assign our own motivations to what animals do. Was the boar thing just a coincidence? Was the boar doing it on purpose? Was it a manifestation of the Island, like the Monster?

"It'll come back around," indeed. Karma, karma, and karma.

Character bits:

Sawyer's real name may be James. And it may not be. Sawyer lies, you know.

Sawyer's mother's name was Laura. His father (whose face we didn't see) wore cowboy boots, killed Laura and himself, and Laura was afraid he would kill Sawyer, too.

Sawyer has never kissed a man. (He said nothing about sex, though.) He never went to college, never went to Disneyland, never voted Democratic (too bad), has never been in love, and has had numerous one-night stands. No surprises there.

Kate has never been to college, never been to Disneyland, never voted, and never had a one-night stand. However, she has been in love, and was married briefly. That was a surprise.

Sawyer and Kate have both killed a man. Charlie just joined that particular club. So has Sayid and Rousseau. And Jin did come home with blood all over him...

Frank Duckett was why Sawyer was in Australia. What struck me was that Sawyer didn't know what his nemesis, the original Sawyer, really looked like. Was Sawyer too little at the time? Was it possible that he never actually saw the guy?

Hibbs (Robert Patrick) said that Sawyer wasn't the killing type, and then tricked Sawyer into killing Duckett. I wonder if we're going to get more of Hibbs. It would probably be too convenient if Hibbs were the original Sawyer.

Sawyer is from Tennessee, and he wears cologne.

Locke had a sister named Jeannie who fell off the monkey bars and broke her neck. He had a foster mother. And for awhile, he had a golden retriever.

Claire seemed to be getting some of her memories back.

Jack, or Matthew Fox, has a large tattoo on the inside of his left arm. I don't remember seeing that one before.

Bits and pieces:

— This episode began with a close-up of young Sawyer's left eye.

— Michael was working on the raft.

— The guns are under lock and key again. For now.

— Christian Shephard misplaced his wallet. Was there something about a wallet in "White Rabbit"?

— Sawyer yelling, "Here, piggy piggy" made me think of Piggy in Lord of the Flies. I haven't read that book since high school. I should probably get back to it sometime soon.


Sawyer: "If you'll excuse me, I have some revenge to tend to."

Charlie: "I killed Ethan. I can bury him."
Hurley: "Yeah. Until he rises from the dead. Dude, I know how this works. This is going to end with you and me running through the jungle, screaming and crying, and he catches me first, because I'm heavy and I get cramps."

Hurley: "Did you ever get that Gulf War syndrome?"
Sayid: "That was the other side."

Kate: "I never wore pink."
(Sawyer drinks)
Kate: "I knew it!"
Sawyer (wryly): "The eighties."

Sawyer: "He peed on my shirt! He took my shirt out of the bag, and peed on it. And you say this ain't personal?"

This episode was so well constructed, written, and acted that every scene was a joy to watch. The story was exceptionally compelling, funny, and moving.

Four out of four polar bears,

Billie Doux loves good television and spends way too much time writing about it.


  1. As this was episode sixteen, I expected a lot of mythology or at least an answer or two. What I got was ever so much better than I could have expected. Easily my favourite of the series so far.

    I have loved Sawyer from the beginning and this one just cemented him as my favourite of the lot. A more conflicted, emotionally wrecked human being it is hard to imagine. I couldn't get over the fact that he had been so manipulated by Hibbs. He can usually see through people like glass. Just strengthens the story about how compelled he is/was to find the "real" Sawyer.

    I loved, loved, loved the I Never game. To watch two people who lie and manipulate others all the time playing a game that is wholly dependent on honesty was compelling. But, something has shifted here. I never quite believed Kate when she "left" him to find his own way back to camp.

    The scene at the bar with Christian was so real it made me cry. I think we have all been in situations where we find it easier to tell the truth to a total stranger than we would the person who should really hear it. But what broke my heart is that not only will Jack never hear what he should have from his father, but if anyone needs some parental validation, it's Sawyer. He, too, will never get it.

    One thought crossed my mind during this episode. Each episode has a flashback and the expression "one's life flashing before one's eyes" popped into my head. If, indeed, these people are all dead (and I am not convinced they are), is this what the flashbacks are?

    Finally, to answer your question, yes. Jack found his father's wallet in Christian's hotel room during "White Rabbit." The details the writers carry through never cease to amaze me. And, the similarities between this show and The Lord of the Flies could be an essay in itself. I'm sure by now someone, somewhere has written one.

  2. Chris, I'm posting this a little late in response to your comment, but somewhere on one of the special features on the DVDs there's a feature about the guy who keeps track of all that stuff for Lost. (I think it's Greg Nations.) I think it's either the Season Two or Season Three DVDs. Some of the Season Two stuff (specific...props) that you wouldn't even expect them to keep track of? They kept track of them all.

    (Pathetically, I think that sounds like an extremely fulfilling job.)

  3. >>Some of the Season Two stuff (specific...props) that you wouldn't even expect them to keep track of? They kept track of them all.

    (Pathetically, I think that sounds like an extremely fulfilling job.)

    It doesn't seem pathetic at all; it would be like being a scribe of god in the creation of a new world and you get to manage the details. Sounds great to me.

  4. Plus, I thought the continuing joke that Australia was Hell was interesting. We could extrapolate that the survivors actually left Hell and are now in Purgatory, couldn't we? (Would that make L.A. heaven? :)

    I always think of Lost when I watch Inception, which uses to flight from Australia to LA to create a sort of sequential process towards salvation.

    I love the way this episode juxtaposes Sawyer, who isn't very good at killing, with Charlie, who is surprisingly good at killing. Sayid acts as a sort of pivot between the two, pointing out that remorse can happen even in unexpected situations. Charlie feels remorse but not guilt for what he did; Sawyer feels remorse for not having yet done what he thought he had done.

  5. Why is it too bad he never voted Democrat? This makes me think Sawyer has a lot of common sense. Since you brought it up, lol. Never should talk politics or religion among strangers, but I still think you write great reviews.


We love comments! We moderate because of spam and trolls, but don't let that stop you! It’s never too late to comment on an old show, but please don’t spoil future episodes for newbies.