Home Featured TV Shows All TV Shows Movie Reviews Book Reviews Articles Frequently Asked Questions About Us

Supergirl: Pilot

"Like her cousin, she was sent here, too, to help us."

Tackling a project like this one must've been hard to crack. I mean, Supergirl has gone through so many comic book incarnations, some of which were incredibly silly. There was even a version of Supergirl that was a shape-changing alien that had absolutely nothing to do with Krypton. Plus the last live action version was, shall we say, less than spectacular. So where do you start? What should be canon, if anything? Is Superman all that relevant to her story beyond a basic set up?

All important questions, which probably should've been answered over the course of the first few episodes. This pilot wasn't so much as packed, but it did feel a touch too full of answers and reveals. At least there weren't so many characters that it was hard to follow, and thankfully our lead makes up for almost all the shortcomings the episode had. I just wish they hadn't felt the need to tackle all of them in the pilot episode.

What saves this pilot from being a mess is Melissa Benoist, who is very likable as Kara and Supergirl. She is easy to invest in, and to root for. She has a quirky, fun and friendly personality, which comes across as genuine and endearing and also a bit self-effacing. More importantly, she manages to pull off the requisite strength of the character. When she takes off the glasses, I can believe she is as powerful as her cousin. That's a hard balance to capture, especially since Benoist is really only the third actor that has tackled this character (no offense to the voice talent behind the animated versions).

I was a little worried at the beginning of the episode that Alex would be just an antagonistic and/or overbearing presence in Kara's life, but in a nice little turn around it seems like she is instead going to be a primary source of support and love. I think a good, positive family dynamic could be a major boon for the long run of the series, so I'm glad it looks like there is a solid basis for it here. It helps that Chyler Leigh is also a very relatable actress, so even when Alex was kind of scolding Kara for revealing herself to the world, it never felt malicious.

Mehcad Brooks as Jimmy Olsen, or James as he likes to be called now, is also a good choice. Elevating him from nerdy sidekick to wizened mentor is both an interesting move and a fun change for the character. I have liked Brooks since his time on True Blood, and he has a nice bit of chemistry going with Benoist. I am glad that the romantic angle wasn't pushed on us too heavily here, and the stuff that was put in worked pretty well. It is also a smart idea to have him in on the secret. Actually, come to think of it, is there anyone in Kara's personal life that doesn't know her secret? That's a nice flip from the traditional superhero nonsense of lying to protect their loved ones.

I wish I could say the rest of the characters worked as well for me. Perhaps it was the focus on feminism that felt off, or maybe just too on the nose, but Cat Grant rubbed me the wrong way. She is a far cry from Perry White, who might be curmudgeonly but was never as mean spirited as Cat seems to be. Kara's friend Winn Schott also bothered me, and not just because he shares a name with a famous Superman villain. His crush seems almost forced, and a bit creepy. Maybe that's intentional, and he did get some of the best lines, so maybe he'll get better.

Then there was Henshaw. What a sanctimonious ass. He's xenophobic and sexist, and apparently that makes him an excellent choice to run a covert operation designed to do something about the 'alien' threat. Except, wouldn't that kind of guy just shoot first and ask questions later? I mean what if some of those prisoners aren't actually bad people? What if Kryptonian law made jay walking a jailable offense? I guess the government is afraid of aliens. There is an obvious political jab I could make there, but I won't.


Dean Cain (Superman from Lois and Clark) and Helen Slater (movie Supergirl) were in the episode for about a minute as Kara's adopted parents. Nice touch. Could we see more of them, please?

I wonder if Chyler Leigh was having flashbacks to the last time she was on a crashing plane?

The baby blanket given to Kara at the end of the episode was a nice nod to the comics.

The villain was so cringe-worthy that he didn't deserve mention in the main body of the review. Which is a shame because Owain Yeoman is a decent actor and did what he could with a role that wasn't the best. I mean did they have to start with a sexist, women must bow before me, villain? Subtlety, writers, have you heard of it?

The ultra tight spandex costume was a nod to some of Supergirl's more revealing costumes of the past. Her more classic costume looks quite a bit better than the promotional image that was released months ago.

I won't get into easter eggs here, but there were several nice nods to comic mythology. Although I was a bit disappointed that "Superman" was never spoken directly except in narration.

The final reveal that Kara's aunt Astra is in charge of the alien underground kind of works. It means we have a Kryptonian big bad, which could be interesting in the long run.


Kara: "I'm not flying around saving people in this thing. I... I wouldn't even wear it to the beach. Where's my cape?"
Winn: "Capes are lame. Tell your cousin I said so. Actually, never, never do that."

Winn: "Uh, if... if I believe the comments on the website, they mentioned a 'female/reptilian boxing in the desert'."
Kara: "I'll tell you all about it in the next crime-fighting lunch hour."
Winn: "Wait, so the Super-Friends are back?"
Kara: "We're not calling ourselves that."

Like both Arrow and The Flash, Supergirl had a major case of pilot-itus, but Melissa Benoist's title character made it better all around.

3 out of 4 costumes.

Samantha M. Quinn spends most of her time in front of a computer typing away at one thing or another; when she has free time, she enjoys pretty much anything science fiction or fantasy-related.


  1. I liked it a lot more than I expected. Mostly because of Melissa Benoist, who is not only adorable, but she also made Kara and Supergirl seem like different people. I like Mehcad Brooks as James, too, and the twist that he is her mentor.

    Didn't like the way too obvious feminism references, or our friend from The Mentalist doing the woman-hating thing. And I can't stand Calista Flockhart, or the character she's playing.

    But I'll definitely keep watching, at least for awhile. Nice review, J.D.

  2. The "girl power" aspect of this pilot was to be expected, and as expected from Hollywood it was too heavy-handed. But other than that I found the pilot enjoyable, mostly due to the incredible charm & screen presence of Melissa Benoist. Plus she looks the part 100%, they couldn't have drawn her better. I can't remember the last time a role has been cast so well. And it's not just her performance in the pilot, but outside the episode she's been every bit as adorable. She even made a cameo appearance in one of the Dubsmashwars(if you don't know what that is, then we can't be friends) videos with the Agents Of SHIELD team, in a bit of cross-brand ecumenism. :)

    I'm not sure about all of the secondary characters, or the plot arcs they're setting up. The whole Fort Rozz(sp?) thing risks being a "Freak Of The Week" trap. I've heard a little bit about what they want to do with Winn & Cat, and I'm intrigued, so we'll see. This show is being made by the same group that's giving us Arrow & The Flash, so they've earned a little patience from me to find their way, especially with such an engaging lead.

    And I just have to say, look at how far we've come since Smallville and "no flights, no tights" :)

  3. umm, actually she's the 3rd actress. Laura Vandervoort played Supergirl on Smallville.

  4. Right, totally forgot there was a proto Supergirl in Smallville. OOPS!

  5. I didn't like this pilot at all. I think it is because they are trying to sell it as a "romantic comedy", and that felt very off to me. It was a little bit like Superman (the original movie) meets Ugly Betty. And at times it really felt like we were stuck in a Phantom Zone watching a recap of Superman (1978).

    I would give it 1/10 Ugly_Betty impersonations, but I won't give up yet. I'll give it a couple of more episodes and hopefully it improves.

  6. I watched this after hearing lots of praise to the leading lady. I liked her, I liked the character, her gleefulness and how she embraced her hero side. But here’s the thing: I don’t dig Superman and the mythology around him. He’s too powerful and so hard to be defeated it takes a lot of the danger and fun away.

    But I went into this pilot hoping for the best. Female (super)heroes are usually awesome, so why not give it a try? Unfortunately, apart from Kara’s personality, this pilot had lots of problems (like cramming too much story and twists, as others pointed out).

    I really disliked the boss of the secret operation. He’s fighting superpowered aliens, a nice alien offers help and he’s a complete idiot? I hope that Kara asking his permission to stop the very corny villain of the week was part of the feminist agenda of the series: by the end of the season she’ll be telling him “screw you, I’ll do whatever I want.”

    Also, like Kara, I have a problem with “Supergirl”. It should be Superwoman. Just imagine for a moment a scenario where Superwoman had been created first: there’s no way they would name the guy version “Superboy”, not in our beloved patriarchal society. If I were Kara, I would fight for Superwoman.

    So, that’s it. Kara’s awesome, but I don’t think I’ll be following her story.

  7. Aren't there going to be any more reviews of Supergirl? I really enjoyed this one!

  8. We're going to be covering the second season of Supergirl and catching up with reviews of season one during The CW's rerun that starts August 1, 2016.

  9. I waited to see if it would make it as a series before watching it now. I can see it's appeal in the comical moments and in it's star. It's not as good when it gets overly dramatic, or when the music gets really loud. Okay, it's a dramatic moment, we get it. I don't need to be blasted by orchestral music all the time. Calista' s character doesn't bother me so far, I'm used to seeing her being really bitchy to Elaine on Ally Mcbeal.

  10. VERY happy you all decided to start reviewing Supergirl!

    After I first watched the pilot and commented here, our team decided to take it on in our podcast, Super Talk at the Coffee Shop.
    I'm still coming here for all Doux Reviews of Supergirl, but if anyone wants something more in-depth, check it out on iTunes https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/super-talk-at-coffee-shop/id1079442482?mt=2 or you can listen to it on our website http://EverybodysHometownGeek.com

    We're still posting the remaining episodes from Season 1 and very much looking forward to Season 2!

    Thanks, Billie and JD!


We love comments! We moderate because of spam and trolls, but don't let that stop you! It’s never too late to comment on an old show, but please don’t spoil future episodes for newbies.